Royal Opera House v Goldscheider

24th April 2019

Royal Opera House v Goldscheider

As a brass player myself I was interested to see the outcome of the appeal to the Civil Division of the Court of Appeal in the case of Royal Opera House v Goldscheider. Although the case did not involve a criminal prosecution, the breaches of Health and Safety Regulations could have led to convictions if a different course had been pursued. As it was the Court had to consider the health and safety aspects of a civil claim for damages by Mr Goldscheider, a professional viola player.

During rehearsals for the performance of the Ring cycle by Wagner at the Royal Opera House, Mr Goldscheider was seated directly in front of the brass section (trumpets, trombones and tuba). The orchestra was positioned in a pit which was partly overhung by the stage. There were ninety performers. Although he wore earplugs, by the third day of rehearsal Mr Goldscheider had suffered injury to hearing which ended his professional career.

It seems that the bell of a trumpet situated immediately behind Mr Goldscheider produced noise levels reaching 133 decibels which is roughly equivalent to that of a jet engine.

The Court found that repositioning of the space between the violas and the brass section and the splitting up of the brass section led to a significant reduction in noise. The Court also found that although earplugs had been issued to players, they made it difficult to hear other players and the conductor and so there was no rule in force that the earplugs had to be worn.

The Court of Appeal decided that the orchestra pit, configured in the way that it had been and with the overhanging stage contributing to the sound pressure, should have been designated a “Hearing Protection Zone”. There should have been appropriate signage. Interestingly, the Court found that although it would have been possible to require earplugs to be worn all the time that would not have been reasonably practicable as it would not have been consistent with the players being able to perform. Therefore, it was right to leave the wearing of the earplugs to the discretion of the players. However, the failure of the Royal Opera House to take the steps necessary to reduce excessive exposure to noise to the lowest level reasonably practicable made it liable to the viola player for the injury he suffered.

Mr Goldscheider’s injuries were caused by a condition caused acoustic shock. It seems that this is the first time that acoustic shock – involving symptoms of tinnitus, dizziness and hypersensitivity to everyday noise has been recognised as an injury which can be compensated by the Court.

The case demonstrates that orchestras and orchestral spaces are not exempt from Health and Safety legislation and that they are work places just as factories are work places.

All orchestras and bands will be worried. However, the Court was keen to allay concerns as far as it could. Having considered the evidence in the case, it seemed to the Court that most musical venues would not be faced with the same problems found at the Royal Opera House. Even where there was an enclosed space for performers, a comparatively small repositioning of the layout of the orchestra pit would provide a marked reduction in the sound pressure and, therefore, potential for injury.

Partner (Member)
Practice Areas
Criminal Law Solicitors
Regulatory
Blog Posts

Unfair dismissal and permanent health insurance (PHI)

22/05/2019

Permanent health insurance (PHI) provides employees with pay during long term sickness or incapacity.…

Read More
Upcoming Events

Managing the workforce in 2019

03/04/2019

If you employ staff or have responsibility for HR, Gotelee Solicitor’s annual employment law…

Read More
News Posts

Employers must record all working time

16/05/2019

If you attended Gotelee’s Employment Law Update at Trinity Park last month you may…

Read More

Testimonials

"We found Rachel Dawson outstanding, polite, professional and caring."

-

"I have used Tracey Laflin at Gotelee on a number of occasions and in my opinion, she is simply the most efficient conveyancing solicitor I have ever worked with. From the outset, she took the time to understand my specific business requirements and to date, she has exceeded all of my expectations."

- Dale Fiddy - Portobello Developments Ltd

"Jade made the process of buying our first home quick, easy and took the stress out of a new chapter of our lives"

-

"Jade Shelton was absolutely fantastic!! Professional and proactive at all times."

- JH

"I would like to say thank you for your help, support and guidance over the last two and a half years. Obviously should I need further assistance in the future I shall not hesitate to call you guys."

-

"Prompt, helpful, polite and very professional service"

-

"This is by far the go-to firm for any issues. You are made to feel valued from the outset and they are so confident in what they do. Wouldn't recommend any other. Thank you Hugh and Max."

- Ros Jones

"Approachable, very efficient, always willing to take my calls and update me."

- SH

"Domini was very fast and efficient in carrying out her work for me - she was also very good at explaining things to me"

-

"“ This is the second time we have used Tracey for the conveyancing to buy our new home. She is always completely approachable, she has helped us along the way with advice and useful tips that has helped lessen the stress. We have complete confidence in her and would not hesitate to recommend her to our friends and family”.  - Peter Dawes, Cater Dawes Financial Planning "

-

Please select preferred method of contact

* We will only contact you by telephone if you select this as primary form of contact. All web enquiries will be stored on our website for 30 days.